Literary Intelligence: Literary Conflict - Rejoinder

An electronic version (off-campus Lehigh access) of this text is available at American Periodicals Series Online, a subscription database of U.S. newspapers from 1740 to 1900 available to individuals and institutions that purchase a license for its use. (Viewing the electronic version of this text will lead you to an external website. Please report dead links to digitlib@lehigh.edu.)

Bibliographic Information

"Literary Intelligence: Literary Conflict - Rejoinder." American Publishers' Circular and Literary Gazette. 13 Mar. 1858: 121-122.

Type: magazine ; Genre: correspondence, literary criticisim, letter to the editor

Abstract

A continuation of the correspondence published in the previous issue concerning claims that Fitz-James O'Brien borrowed the plot for The Diamond Lens from an unpublished manuscript by William North. Consists of a letter by Augustus Maverick, quoting in full a letter by Charles Bailey Seymour to Maverick on the matter.

People who Created this Work

Seymour, Charles Bailey: Includes a letter by Seymour, who served as the literary executor of William North.

People Mentioned in this Work

Bellew, Frank Henry Temple: Seymour mentions discussing the controversy surrounding The Diamond Lens with "Mr. O'Brien's friend, a celebrated artist of this City... who was also one of Mr. N[orth]'s friends." This artist admitted that he gave the idea for the story to O'Brien, but had forgotten that North had told him this idea long ago. The artist was most likely Frank Bellew, who was a friend of both authors and was later identified by William Winter as one of two possible sources for the idea behind The Diamond Lens.
North, William: Seymour claims that North read him a story entitled Micro-Cosmos with a plot very similar to O'Brien's Diamond Lens.
O'Brien, Fitz-James: Maverick continues to assert that O'Brien borrowed from William North.
Seymour, Charles Bailey: Augustus Maverick uses Seymour's letter as evidence of O'Brien's plagiarism. He identifies Seymour as the literary executor of William North.

Related Works

"Literary Intelligence: Literary Conflict." American Publishers' Circular and Literary Gazette. 6 Mar. 1858: 111-112. [more about this work]
[O'Brien, Fitz-James]. "The Diamond Lens." The Atlantic Monthly. Jan. 1858: 354-367. [more about this work]